Paper determination without a hearing (and bringing a McKenzie friend): the rent tribunal tenant walkthrough 2026
A rent challenge at the First-tier Tribunal does not always need you to attend a hearing. You can often elect a determination on the papers, where the tribunal decides on the documents alone. It is quicker and less stressful, but it puts all the weight on your written evidence. This walkthrough explains how to decide between a paper determination and an oral hearing, how to elect one, and, if you do attend, how a McKenzie friend can support you. It includes template wording for both choices.
Not every rent challenge needs you to stand up in front of a panel. The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) can decide a rent-determination case in one of two ways: at an oral hearing that you attend, or on the papers, where it reaches a decision on the written evidence alone without anyone attending. Both are normal. Choosing well between them is one of the quietly important decisions in a rent challenge, and many tenants make it without realising they had a choice at all.
This walkthrough explains how to decide between a paper determination and an oral hearing, how to elect the paper route properly, and, if you do attend, how a McKenzie friend can support you on the day. It includes template wording for both choices. It pairs with our guide to the tribunal's directions order, which is usually where the choice first comes up, and our hearing-day guide, which covers what happens if you attend.
The two routes, plainly
An oral hearing is what most people picture: a date, a venue or video link, and a panel that hears from both sides. You can explain your evidence, answer questions, and respond to anything the landlord says.
A determination on the papers has no attendance at all. The tribunal reads the written evidence both sides have filed and decides. It is faster, it costs you no travel or time off work, and it removes the nerves of speaking in public. But it gives you no chance to add anything or respond on the day, so your bundle has to be complete and self-explanatory before you choose it.
The legal test is the same either way: what rent the property would reasonably command on the open market, taking its condition into account. The route only changes how your evidence reaches the tribunal, not the standard it is judged against.
How to decide
Ask yourself three honest questions:
-
Is my written evidence strong and self-explanatory? If your comparable rents are clear, well-sourced and labelled, and the property's condition is shown in dated photographs, paper may carry your case comfortably.
-
Are the facts genuinely disputed? If the landlord disagrees about condition, about which comparables are fair, or about whether the notice was even valid, you will probably want to be there to answer those points.
-
Will I want to respond to the landlord on the day? If you expect them to raise arguments you would like to meet head-on, a hearing gives you that chance; paper does not.
If your case is clean and your evidence speaks for itself, paper is often the sensible, low-stress choice. If there is a real argument in the case, a hearing keeps your options open. When genuinely unsure, lean towards attending.
How to elect a paper determination
You normally indicate your preference when you reply to the directions order, or you can write to the tribunal separately. The key is to make sure your bundle is finished first, because once the case is decided on paper you will not get to add to it.
To the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) Case reference: [number] Property: [address]
I am the tenant in the above rent-determination case. I confirm that I am content for the case to be determined on the papers, without an oral hearing.
I have filed all the evidence I wish to rely on, namely [brief list, e.g. my comparable-rent schedule, photographs of the property, and a copy of the Form 4A notice], and I have exchanged it with the landlord as directed. I do not require a hearing.
If the tribunal considers a hearing necessary, I would of course attend.
[Your name and date]
That last line matters: it tells the tribunal you are co-operative and will turn up if it decides a hearing is needed after all.
If you attend: bringing a McKenzie friend
If you choose, or are asked, to attend a hearing, you do not have to face it alone, and you do not need a lawyer. You can bring a McKenzie friend: someone who sits with you to provide quiet support. A McKenzie friend can take notes, help you keep your papers in order, and give you quiet advice during the hearing. They are not your legal representative and do not normally address the tribunal for you, although the tribunal has a discretion to allow a friend to speak in some situations.
Your McKenzie friend can be a relative, a friend, or a volunteer. It is good manners, and good practice, to tell the tribunal in advance that you intend to bring one, and to give their name, so there is no surprise on the day.
To the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) Case reference: [number] Property: [address]
I am the tenant in the above case, which is listed for a hearing on [date]. I wish to be accompanied at the hearing by a McKenzie friend, [name], who will provide quiet support and assistance. They will not act as my legal representative. I would be grateful for the tribunal's confirmation that this is acceptable.
[Your name and date]
What happens after a paper determination
If the case is decided on the papers, the tribunal issues its decision in writing once it has considered the evidence, usually within a few weeks. You receive the decision and normally the reasons for it. It sets the rent the tribunal considers appropriate.
Two reforms in force from 1 May 2026 make this far less daunting than it used to be: the tribunal cannot set the rent higher than the landlord proposed, and the new rent takes effect from the date of the decision rather than being backdated. Together they remove the old fear that challenging might leave you worse off. Keep the written decision safe; it is the authority for the rent you now pay.
The takeaway
Paper or hearing is not a question of which is stronger; it is a question of which lets your evidence be seen at its best. A clean, complete, well-indexed case can be decided fairly on paper. A case with real arguments in it deserves to be heard in person, and if it is, a McKenzie friend can make the day far less lonely. Either way, the post-May-2026 rules mean a challenge is now a low-risk thing to bring.
If RentSOS found grounds to challenge your increase, your pack is built to be filed as a self-contained written bundle, which is exactly what a paper determination needs, and exactly what you would hand up at a hearing too.
Frequently Asked Questions
+Can my rent challenge be decided without a hearing?
Often, yes. The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) can decide a rent-determination case on the papers, meaning it reaches a decision on the written evidence both sides have filed without anyone attending a hearing. This is sometimes called a determination on the papers or a paper determination. You usually indicate your preference when you respond to the tribunal's directions. The tribunal can still decide a hearing is needed even if both sides are content with paper, but where the evidence is clear and the issues are narrow, a paper determination is common, quicker and less stressful than attending in person.
+Is a paper determination better than a hearing for tenants?
It depends on your case. A paper determination is faster, costs you no travel or time off, and avoids the nerves of speaking in front of a panel. The trade-off is that you cannot answer questions or respond to the landlord on the day, so your written evidence has to stand entirely on its own. If your comparable-rent evidence is strong, clearly labelled and self-explanatory, paper is often the sensible choice. If the facts are genuinely disputed, your evidence needs explaining, or you expect the landlord to raise points you would want to answer, an oral hearing usually serves you better.
+How do I ask for a determination on the papers?
You normally state your preference in writing when you reply to the directions order, or you can write to the tribunal separately. Say clearly that you are content for the case to be determined on the papers without a hearing, and confirm that you have filed all the evidence you wish to rely on. Make sure your written bundle is complete before you do this, because once the case is decided on paper you will not get a chance to add to it. If you change your mind before the decision, tell the tribunal promptly and explain why you now think a hearing is needed.
+What is a McKenzie friend and can I bring one?
A McKenzie friend is someone who attends a hearing with you to provide quiet support: they can sit with you, take notes, help you stay organised, and give you quiet advice. They are not your legal representative and do not usually address the tribunal on your behalf, though the tribunal has a discretion to allow a friend to speak in some circumstances. You do not need to be a lawyer to have one, and they can be a relative, friend, or volunteer. It is courteous to tell the tribunal in advance that you intend to bring a McKenzie friend, and to give their name, so there is no surprise on the day.
+Does choosing paper or a hearing change my chances of winning?
Neither route is inherently stronger; what matters is matching the route to your evidence. A paper determination rewards a clear, complete, well-indexed written case. A hearing rewards the ability to explain and defend that case in person. The tribunal applies the same legal test either way: what rent the property would reasonably command on the open market, taking account of its condition. Choose the route that lets your evidence be seen at its best. If in doubt, and your case has any real argument in it, attending a hearing keeps your options open.
+If the case is decided on the papers, when do I find out the result?
The tribunal issues its decision in writing after it has considered the evidence, usually within a few weeks, though timescales vary. You receive the decision and, normally, the reasons for it. The decision sets the rent the tribunal considers appropriate. Under the reforms in force from 1 May 2026, the tribunal cannot set the rent higher than the landlord proposed, and the new rent takes effect from the date of the decision rather than being backdated, which removes a long-standing deterrent to challenging. Keep the written decision safe, as it is the authority for the rent you now pay.
Check your rent increase
Find out if your landlord’s Section 13 notice is valid. Free, anonymous, takes 2 minutes.
Free to check · £14.99 only if we find grounds
Keep reading
Related guides on tenant rights and rent increases.
Is my landlord raising the rent just to force me out? What the law actually allows
A large rent increase can feel like a quiet eviction, especially now that no-fault eviction is gone. But a Section 13 must reflect genuine market rent, not what would make you leave. Here is where you stand.
I already started paying the higher rent: can I still challenge it or get it back?
Paying the new rent for a few months does not automatically lock you into it. Whether you can still challenge or reclaim depends on two separate questions, and this walkthrough explains both.
If I challenge my rent increase, will my landlord just try again next year?
Worried that challenging your rent increase just delays the next one? Here is what stops your landlord raising the rent again, why a successful challenge lowers your baseline for good, and why challenging is still worth it.
Is it worth challenging my rent increase? Your real chances at the tribunal
Before you spend the fee and the hours preparing an evidence bundle, there is a fair question worth answering honestly: is challenging your rent increase actually worth it? What are your real chances of the tribunal reducing the rent, and how do you know before you apply whether you have a genuine case or are about to pay to confirm the very increase you were fighting? The honest answer is that it is not a coin toss and it is not a lottery. Whether a challenge is worth it comes down to two things you can check in advance: whether the notice is procedurally valid, and whether the proposed rent is above the real market rent. Get those two answers and you already know most of what you need. This walkthrough gives you a straight, no-hype view of when a challenge is worth running, when it is not, and how the rules that changed on 1 May 2026 shifted the odds in tenants' favour. England only, periodic assured tenancies, Section 13.
Will challenging my rent increase hurt my credit score or references?
It is one of the quietest fears there is, and it stops a lot of renters from ever challenging a rent increase. Not the fear of the tribunal itself, but the worry about what it does to your record. Will it show up on your credit report? Will your landlord give you a bad reference? Could you end up on some kind of tenant blacklist that follows you to the next place? The reassuring answer is that a rent challenge is not a court judgment, does not appear on your credit file, and cannot lawfully brand you a difficult tenant. There is one real risk to your record, and it has nothing to do with challenging: it is falling into rent arrears. This walkthrough explains exactly what a challenge does and does not do to your credit, your references, and your future tenancies, so you can decide without the fear doing your thinking for you. England only, periodic assured tenancies, Section 13.
Moving out while your rent tribunal challenge is still live: what happens?
You stood up to the rent increase and applied to the First-tier Tribunal to challenge it. Then life moves: a new job, a better place, a relationship change, or simply the realisation that this home no longer works at this price. Now you are wondering what happens to the challenge you started. Does it just collapse when you hand in your notice? Does the rent you are arguing about still matter once you have a leaving date? Should you withdraw the application, or let it run? This walkthrough sorts out the practical mechanics of moving out while a rent challenge is still live, what the determined rent does and does not affect once you are on your way out, and the traps to avoid so that leaving does not cost you money you did not need to spend. England only, periodic assured tenancies, Section 13.